Register Here | Login | My Account | Shopping Cart | Customer Service | Search| Items in Cart (0) | Quotes (0)
Call 1-800-369-6671
(Military/Intl Sales - 214-616-6180)
LIGHT TOWERS IN STOCK
       
 

Vast Inventory for Fast Shipping. Custom Builds Available, Rentals and Sales.
Most items in stock for fast shipping!! UPS Ship Map Credit cards & Paypal Accepted
Home - Articles You're NOT logged in, Please log in   

Search:
Company Information

Product #:

         
ATEX and IEC Ex Flame-proof Explosion Proof Lighting & Equipment
Explosion Proof Lights
Explosion Proof Motors - Motors for Hazardous Locations
Industrial and Vaporproof Emergency Failsafe Lighting
Industrial Cord Reels and Tool Taps
Industrial Work Area Heaters
Machine Vision Lights
Megatower™
QC Series Industrial Portable Lighting - Quick Change Mount
Rig Lights
Stadium lights
String Lights and Temporary Light Stringers
Tank Cleaning Lights
Three Phase Motor Soft Starters
Vapor Proof LED Lights
Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs)
Vehicle Mounting Plates
Workboat Light Fixtures & Lighting Equipment
Yacht Engine Room Lights
Color Changing LED RGB Lighting
Explosion Proof Cord Reels
GOLIGHT Spotlights
Larson FUTURE - Lease Lighting
Remote Area Lighting and Scene Lights
Utility Bucket Mount, Receiver Hitch & Trailer Mount Lighting
Aevum Control Lighting and Equipment - IIoT
Butane and Solvent Extraction Room Lighting and Equipment
DC to DC Transformers and Power Supplies
Explosion Proof Fans & Blowers
Explosion Proof Paint Spray Booth Approved Lights
Explosion Proof String Lights
Explosion Proof Switchgear & Controls
Fleet Service Lights and Lighting Equipment
Industrial Equipment Trailers
Industrial Handlamps & Droplights
ISO 14644/FS-209E Clean Room Lighting
LED Blasting Lights
Night Time Fishing Lights
Portable AC Power Supply Units
Portable Power Distribution Panels
Power Distribution Panels with KVA Transformers
Self-Contained Lighting
Service Pit Lighting
Solar Generators & Solar Powered Lighting
Agricultural Farm Equipment Lighting & Beacons
Explosion Proof Cameras & Surveillance Systems
Explosion Proof Emergency Lights
Explosion Proof Heaters
Garage & Gas Station Canopy Lights
LED Grow Lights
LED Lights
NDT Ultraviolet Lights
Portable Hazardous Location Lighting
Radio Communication Towers and Equipment
Salt Water Processing Equipment
Shelter & Tent Lighting
Thermal Monitoring Cameras and Systems
48V LED Equipment Lights
ATEX Rated Explosion Proof Lights
Automotive Lighting
Class Rated Signals, Alarms, and Systems
Hazardous Location Area Lights and Portable Lighting
HID Equipment Lights
Hot Work Permit Lighting and Equipment
Hunting Lights
Industrial lasers
Industrial Transformers
Light Towers
Outdoor Lighting
Remote Security and Surveillance Systems
Temporary Construction Lights
Vehicle Mounted Spotlights
Equipment & Heavy Machinery LED Light Package Fitouts
Phase Converters - Single to Three Phase
Marine Shore Power Cords and Equipment
24 Volt Military Lights
Disaster Relief / First Responders / Search & Rescue Lighting
Plastic Handcuff Key
110/120 Volt Flood Lights
Post Mount Spotlights
Magnetic Work Lights
Crank-up Light Masts
**********    
Intrinsically Safe Lights
Military Flashlights
LED Waterproof Lanterns
Work Area Lights
12 Volt Flood Lights
**********    
**********    
Boat Spotlights
New Boat Lights
HID Boat Lights
Boat Dock Lights
**********    
Remote Control Lights
Control Lights
Tow Lights
Magnetic Control Lights
**********    
NEW Lights and New Products
Evaporative Coolers
Police Equipment
AC/DC Transformers
Power Supplies
**********    
Military Spotlights 24V
Infrared Filters, Covert Covers, and Blackout IR Lenses
Military Equipment
Ultralife Batteries
Remote Control Pan Tilt Base
**********    
Larson Electronics Spotlights
Larson Electronics Parts
Replacement Lamps
Cords - Brackets
Portable Wheeled Generators
Non-Hazardous Location Extension Cords / Plugs / Outlets
**********    
HID Work Lights
HID Dive Lights
HID Off Road Lights
Acro Lights HID Lights
Halogen Lights
**********    
Acro Light Flashlight
Xenon HID Flashlights
Powerlight Flashlight
HID Flashlights
Xenon Flashlights
**********    
LED Status Lights
Forklift Lights
Tractor Lights
HID Post Mount Lights
Roof Mount Lights
Post Mount Light parts
**********    
Flashlight Holder
Magnet Spotlight Base
Tripods-Magnetic Base
**********    
Recharging Spotlights
Fire Rescue Lights
LED Street Lights
Utility Lights
**********    
Hazard Lights
Strobe Lights - Battery Operated
Strobes & Beacons
Strobe Light Bars
**********    
Headlights - Headlamps - Hard Hat Lights
Flashlights
**********    
Suction Mount Lights
Magnetic Spotlights
12/24 Volt Spotlights
Gifts For Men
**********    
**********    
New 12 / 24 Volt Lights
Explosion Proof Accessories and Replacement Parts
Explosion Proof Lighting
Explosion Proof Hand Lamps (Drop Lights)
Explosion Proof Lights - Stand/Dolly
Explosion Proof Tank Lights
Explosion Proof Phones and Intercoms
Explosion Proof Extension Cords
Black Friday & Cyber Monday Specials
Crane Lights
Explosion Proof Light Rentals
General Light Rentals
Light Tower and Light Plant Rentals
Power Distribution Rentals
**********    
Power Plant Lighting
Refinery lights
Environmental Services Lights
Aerospace Lights
Chemical Plant Lights
Food Grade Safe Lights
Film and Entertainment Lights
Handheld Meters and Devices
Waste Water Treatment Lights
Mining Lights
Ship Yard Lights
Work Site Lighting
         

   
11/15/13 LED versus Fluorescent: Lumens per Watt is Only Part of the Story

Article- November 10, 2013 By Larson Electronics.com

Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lights

Larson Electronics Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lights


When considering lighting upgrades most professionals consider the initial outlay costs and compare them against the expected savings over a year in order to form a realistic picture of cost effectiveness. When doing a direct comparison between an old system versus a new and considering the savings produced in the form of reduced energy consumption, it is indeed possible to form a basic savings expectation, however this is not a comprehensive view and leaves out a variety of important factors that can affect real world results. Particularly in the case of comparing fluorescent lighting to newer LED technology, there are many less than obvious factors that must be taken into account if an accurate savings expectation can be formulated.


Due to new energy efficiency standards fluorescent lighting technology has undergone several changes that have resulted in an overall significant improvement of its energy efficiency. Older style T12 lamps and magnetic ballasts have been phased out and are being replaced with newer T8 lamps and electronic ballasts which provide much improved performance. Today it is commonplace to find T8 fixtures producing on the order of 80 to 100 lumens per watt of output, putting fluorescent lighting at the top of the efficient lighting ratings in terms of lumen per watt efficiency. However, this does not tell the whole story, and other factors come into play which affect the real world efficiency of fluorescent lighting and brings it a little more down to earth. This is not to say that fluorescent lighting is not an efficient and effective lighting technology, not by any means; only that when comparing fluorescent lighting to other lighting technologies, it is necessary to consider other contributing factors besides just lumen to watt ratios.



LED lighting technology has generated a great deal of excitement in the lighting industry as of late due to its high efficiency and great longevity. Although currently more costly to produce, LED lighting is quickly coming down in price while its lumen per watt ratios continue to climb, putting it into direct competition with linear fluorescent lighting for king of the hill of efficient lighting. LED lighting has yet to become a “mature” technology, but its rapid development is bringing about this maturation quickly, and as of this writing LEDs are now available which do indeed provide some stiff competition for energy efficient fluorescents. LED lighting currently has a real world lumen to watt ratio of around 60 to 100 lumens per watt, with 100 lumens per watt being less common than with fluorescent fixtures, and an average around 80 lumens per watt being closer to the norm. Despite this slightly lower lumen to watt ratio and higher production cost, because of other mitigating factors we will discuss in a moment, LEDs do in fact provide the potential to outperform fluorescents in some applications.


As we mentioned earlier, lumen per watt is the usual defining comparison when most people consider which lighting is the most efficient. But lumen to watt ratios only tell part of the story. One major variation between LED and fluorescent lamps affecting actual lighting performance is their radiating angle. A fluorescent tube radiates its light output 306 degrees over the entire surface of the tube. LED tubes however radiate at an angle of 110 to 120 degrees. Because of this, the actual amount of light reaching the targeted area is greatly affected by radiating angle. For instance, if we were to draw a line straight along the middle of a fluorescent tube, and assume the lower half radiates light downwards, and the upper half radiates upwards, we could roughly say that only half the lamps output is being radiated downwards towards the target area, and the upper half is lost and wasted illuminating unneeded space.


An LED tube on the other hand radiates all of its light downwards. So, if we have an LED tube and a fluorescent tube, and both produce a total of 1500 lumens and have a lumen to watt ratio of 80, then we can say that the fluorescent is only putting 750 lumens on target, while the LED is putting the full 1500 lumens on target. In effect, half the light output of the fluorescent tube is wasted. Granted, this is a big oversimplification, but it demonstrates the point of just why lumen per watt ratios only tell part of the story when it comes to actual efficiency. Even with reflectors and hoods in place, fluorescent lamps lose a significant portion of their light to poor directional control and diffusion, reducing their actual operating efficiency. In applications such as office space or high bay lighting, this can have a significant effect on how practical and cost effective upgrading to a newer lighting system, LED or fluorescent, will actually be. For instance, we could install lower power LED fixtures instead of fluorescent lamps, and still deliver the same amount of light to the targeted area, yet realize even greater reductions in energy use.



Another consideration often overlooked when comparing cost effectiveness between these two lighting technologies is overall operating costs rather than just costs associated with energy use. Lamp life is considered part of overall operating costs, and with LEDs usually lasting twice as long as fluorescent tubes LEDs have the upper hand. However, fluorescent lamps also utilize a ballast, and with ballasts having a service life on average of 50,000 hours, they will have to be replaced every second relamping, significantly increasing operating costs. LEDs on the other hand are entirely solid state and will not require this added expense.


As can be seen, there is much more to determining actual efficiency and cost effectiveness when comparing competing lighting technologies. Factors such as intended application, design differences, and expected ROI will play a large role in determining just which upgrade solution best fits your needs. The best results are obtained when one gains a broader understanding of all the factors that set one lighting technology apart from another, and then applies that knowledge towards forming a real world expectation of performance.





Related Categories/Products
Category/Product (click on link below for more information)
Explosion Proof Lights
Explosion Proof Lights
Explosion Proof Lighting
Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lights
Explosion Proof LED Lights
Explosion Proof Paint Spray Booth Approved Lights
Paint Spray Booth Lights
Ceiling & Pendant Mount Explosion Proof Lights
Class 1 Division 2 Lights
Linear Class 1 Division 2 Lights
Explosion Proof Incandescent / Fluorescent Hand Lamps
Paint Spray Booth LED Lights
Class 2 Div 1 Coal & Grain Lights
Offshore Hazardous Location Lights
Explosion Proof LED Lights for Hazardous Areas
Class 1 Division 2 Paint Spray Booth Lights
Class 1 Division 2 Paint Spray Booth Lights
Power Plant Lighting
Refinery lights
Chemical Plant Lights
Aerospace Lights
Ship Yard Lights
Food Grade Safe Lights
LED Tubes
Fleet Service Lights and Lighting Equipment
Explosion Proof Light - Waterproof Fluorescent Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booth, Rigs - 4 foot, 2 l
Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lights for Paint Booths, Oil Rigs, Boats -2 foot - 2 lamp -Multi-voltage
Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lights for Paint Booths, Oil Rigs, Boats -2 foot - 2 lamp -Multi-voltage
HAL-48-2L Fluorescent Light - C1 D II - Hazardous Location Areas - Multi-voltage
Class 1 Division 2 Fluorescent Light for Corrosion Resistant Requirements (Saltwater)
Explosion Proof LED Paint Spray Booth light - Class 1 Div 1 - Class 1 Div 2 - T6 - 7,000 Lumens
Class 1 Div 2 LED Light Fixture - 4 Foot 2 Lamp - Marine Grade Aluminum Light - LED Rig Light
Class 1 Division 2 Hazardous Location LED Light - Corrosion Resistant for Marine - C1D2/C2D2
Explosion Proof LED Paint Spray Booth Fixture - Class I, Div. I - 4, 2 Foot LED Bulbs - 5040 Lumen
Class I Division 1 & 2 Explosion Proof 150 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture 16,000 Lumens- Pendant
18 Watt T8-Style LED Tube Lamp - LED Bulb Retrofit, Replacement, or Upgrade for Fluorescent Lights
LED Bulb- T5 - 12 Watts - 4 Foot replacement or upgrade for fluorescent light fixtures
Low Profile - Explosion Proof Light - 4 Foot, 4 Lamp - Class 1 Division 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated
Low Profile Explosion Proof Light - Class 1 Div. 2 (Class 2 Div 2 - Class 2 Div 1) - 4Ft, 4 Lamp
Low Profile Explosion Proof Light - Class 1 Div. 2 (Class 2 Div 2 - Class 2 Div 1) - 4Ft, 4 Lamp
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4Ft, 2 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T8
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 2 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T5HO
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 2 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T5HO
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 6 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T8
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 6 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T8
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 6 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T5HO
Low Profile, Explosion Proof Light - 4ft, 6 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated - T5HO
Low Profile LED Explosion Proof Light - 4ft. 2 lamp - Class I, Div. II - Paint Spray Booth Rated
Low Profile, Explosion Proof LED Light - 4ft, 4 Lamps - Class 1 Divison 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated
Low Profile, Explosion Proof LED Light - 4ft, 4 Lamps - Class 1 Divison 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated
Low Profile Hazardous Area Fluorescent Light - Lay-In Mount -Front Load Troffer - Class 1, Div. 2
Low Profile Hazardous Area Fluorescent Light - Lay-In Mount Front Load Troffer - Class 1, Div. 2
Low Profile Hazardous Area LED Light - Lay-In Mount -Front Load Troffer - Class 1, Div. 2
Explosion Proof Emergency LED light - 4 foot 2 lamp - Backup Ballast - Class 1 & 2 LED Light
Hazardous Location Lighting - 150 Watts - 17,500 Lumens - C1D2 / C2D1 - Surface Mount
Hazardous Area Emergency Fluorescent Light - Lay-In Mount - 2X4 Front Load Troffer - Failsafe - LED
Class 1 Div 2 LED Pivoting Light - 4 Foot 2 Lamp - Offshore LED Rig Light - Meets USCG Specs
Low Profile Hazardous Area Fluorescent Light - 4 Foot 2 Lamp - Lay-In Mount -Front Load Troffer
Low Profile Surface Mount Explosion Proof Fluorescent Light - 20,000 Lumens - Paint Booth Approved
Low Profile Explosion Proof Fluorescent Light Fixture - 2 Foot 4 Lamp Compact Design - 8000 Lumens
2 FT LED Bulb - T8 - 10 Watt - UL Listed - Fluorescent T8 LED Replacement/Retrofit Lamp
3 FT LED Bulb - T8 - 14 Watt - UL Listed - Fluorescent T8 LED Replacement/Retrofit Lamp
6 FT LED Bulb - T8 - 36W - 4500 Lumens - UL Listed - Fluorescent T8 LED Replacement/Retrofit Lamp
18 Watt LED Bulb - 3 Foot T8 Lamp - Replacement or Upgrade for Fluorescent Lights
150W Explosion Proof High Bay LED Light Fixture - 17500 Lumens - C1D1 - Paint Spray Booth Approved
Explosion Proof Fluorescent Lighting - 2 Foot, 2 Lamp - Surface and Pendant Mount
Low Profile Explosion Proof Fluorescent Light - 2 Foot 4 Lamp Compact - Surface and Pendant Mount
Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 300 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booth Approved
Low Profile Explosion Proof LED Light - 2x4 Lay-In Troffer Class 1/2 Div 1/2 Paint Spray Booth Rated
Low Profile Explosion Proof LED Light - 2x2 Lay-In Troffer -Class 1 Div 1&2 -Paint Spray Booth Rated
Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 450 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booth Approved
Low Profile Explosion Proof LED Light - 2x4 Lay-In Mount - Class 1 Div 2 - Paint Spray Booth Rated
347/480V Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 150 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booths
480V Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 450 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture -140°- Paint Spray Booth
Class I Div 2 Pivoting Light - 4 Foot 2 Lamp - Offshore Fluorescent Rig Light - Meets USCG Specs
Rear Access Paint Spray Booth Lay-In Panel Light Fixture - 4ft, 6 Lamp - Class 1 Div. 2 - T5HO
Ceiling Mount Explosion Proof 150 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booth Approved
Integrated Explosion Proof LED Paint Spray Booth Light - Class 1 Div 1 - Class 1 Div 2 - 8,000 Lumen
Dimmable Explosion Proof LED Paint Spray Booth light - Class 1 & 2 Div 1 - T6 - 5,750 Lumens
Class I Div 2 LED Pivoting Light - 4 Foot Integrated Lamp - Offshore LED Rig Light - Meets USCG Spec
160 Watt Class 1 Division 2 Hazardous Location Integrated LED Light -Corrosion Resistant -Marine Use
100 Watt Explosion Proof LED Light - 2x2 Lay-In Troffer - Class 1 Div 1 & 2 -Paint Spray Booth Rated
Explosion Proof 150 Watt Low Bay LED Light Fixture - 140° Spread - Paint Booth Approved - C1D1
Dimmable Class 1 Division 2 Hazardous Location LED Light - Corrosion Resistant for Marine Saltwater
Dimmable Class 1 Div 2 LED Light Fixture - 4 Foot 2 Lamp - Marine Grade Aluminum Light Fixture - LED
Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 300 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - 140 Degree Beam Angle
40 Watt Hazardous Locations Low Profile LED Light Fixture - Class 1 Div 2 - ATEX Rated - 120/277V AC
100 Watt Hazardous Locations Low Profile LED Light Fixture - Class 1 Div 2 - ATEX Rated - 120/277V
185 Watt Hazardous Locations Low Profile LED Light Fixture - Class 1 Div 2 - ATEX Rated - 120/277V
80 Watt Hazardous Locations Low Profile LED Light Fixture - Class 1 Div 2 - ATEX Rated - 120/277V AC
Class 1 Division 1 Explosion Proof 450 Watt High Bay LED Light Fixture - Paint Spray Booth Approved
Home | Contact Us | Return Policy | Privacy Policy | Security Policy | Copyright © 2006-2018. All Rights Reserved.